Sunday, February 12, 2006

Fanatical Fiasco

As a devout atheist, I find a large amount of the recent arguments on religion and spiritual-based morality somewhat entertaining, if not superfluous and tiring at times. Needless to say, I stand here awe-struck at the degree and extent of the uproar around the world that the Danish cartoons have caused.

Free-speech is one thing, but insulting religions is another. The Danish newspapers must have been aware that their little excercise in free-speech would lead to insurmountable levels of trouble. Although I strongly believe the Danish government should not apologise on the behalf of a couple of insignificant Danish rags, one has to ask was it really worth it?

Mind you, had the Danish newspapers published a Holocaust-denial story they may have found themselves in a courtroom. Strangely enough, the ever-shouting champion of free-speech, America, has not had any newspapers publish the cartoons, I believe. However, their flags are still being burnt alongside Danish ones, though we could blame the socilialists of Venezuela for that.

It is a great shame that a large number of Muslims live in undesirable conditions under corrupt dictatorships and oligarchies. Thus they, like the past and present Marxists of Latin America, look towards the West when casting the blame for their miserable states. A lack of money isn't the only issue however, as Princeton University economist Alan B. Krueger discusses:

...countries like Saudi Arabia and Bahrain, which have spawned relatively many terrorists, are economically well off yet lacking in civil liberties. Poor countries with a tradition of protecting civil liberties are unlikely to spawn suicide terrorists. Evidently, the freedom to assemble and protest peacefully without interference from the government goes a long way to providing an alternative to terrorism.

To back this up, one doesn't have to look far to see that a large number of terrorist leaders, both past and present, have been well-educated (often in the West) and from middle-class families (examples: a son of a lawyer, a doctor, a Rolex-wearing doctor, an engineer and a PhD in engineering).

One can argue the Muslim protests were inevitable with such high levels of tension. Regardless, it shows that economic liberalism and wealth isn't the only thing that the Muslim world needs. Also, I'd be selling any Danish company shares you may have.

Update I: I've been informed that the cartoons were published months ago in an Egyptian paper with no riots, and it has been the Imans of late stirring shit, so to speak.

Update II: An interesting piece in The Economist which somewhat echoes my sentiments with these words:

It is not a good idea for newspapers to insult people's religious or any other beliefs just for the sake of it. But that is and should be their own decision, not a decision for governments, clerics or other self-appointed arbiters of taste and responsibility. In a free country people should be free to publish whatever they want within the limits set by law.

Update III: The odd American paper has published the cartoons.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Come on Engels, there's a difference between poking fun at a religious belief (and the cartoons were pretty innocuous at that) and denying an actual historical event that killed upwards of 6 million people.

Mind you, I'm of the opinion holocaust denial should be legal - it would be better to have such idiocy out in the open where it can be viewed and ruthlessly debunked.

As for the cartoons - the whole response was ridiculous, and fueled by the fact A) Most of the rioters hadn't seen the toons, and only relied on what their imams told them b) Said Imams falsified a few extra (more insulting) toons.

The toons were actually printed last year - months ago - but the outrage was delayed, since the paper probably isn't read by any Muslims.

Additionally, the toons themselves were printed months ago in an Egyptian paper -

http://evilpundit.com/archives/013196.html

No riots then.

The whole thing strikes me as a rather calculated anti-West skullduggery by the usual suspects (Syria and Iran).

8:41 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

So, in short, you're correct about the real source - craptacular regimes that, having failed their citizens economically, socially, politically and every other aspect, has to keep looking for an external enemy so they won't get overthrown.

The day Muslim middle-eastern countries get are preoccupied with intelligent design, gay marriage and other more "pressing" religious matters.... the better.

8:43 pm  
Blogger Engels said...

Hmmm, denial of six million deaths and mocking a prophet adored by millions. Tough call.

I was aware of the cartoons being published months ago, and it only coming to light now via Imans. I heard a guy got death threats in Jordan after publishing them, which he only did to show the how evil the West are.

I think they're all crazy.

9:11 pm  
Blogger Engels said...

I was also aware that certain Imans were not being entirely honest. I've heard that Islam means peace.

Tisk tisk.

9:26 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank you!
[url=http://tcsgyecb.com/axyr/rlbz.html]My homepage[/url] | [url=http://exmvqudy.com/hlba/vsgv.html]Cool site[/url]

5:08 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home